Search This Blog

Showing posts with label food taste testings. Show all posts
Showing posts with label food taste testings. Show all posts

Sunday, February 6, 2011

Pistachio Ice Cream Smackdown

Our Protagonist cannot live by eating out alone; no, sometimes he must brave his own kitchen to scrounge up sustenance.  That is, when he doesn't have time to whip up something gourmet-ish.  Case in point; a recent exploration of the eternal question, "Which pistachio ice cream is really the best?"  In order to come to a conclusion, a series of highly scientific tastings ensued involving four different brands, two of which were gelati, rather than ice cream: Ciao Bella and Talenti gelati, and Haagen-Dazs and Ben & Jerry's ice creams.  Here are the tasting notes:

Ciao Bella: decent flavor, but a gritty, not smooth texture.  Disappointing because of the texture.

Haagen-Dazs: very creamy, but the pistachios were chopped up into minuscule chips; the flavor was so subtle to be virtually non-existent!  Not what a pistachio lover would be looking for.

Ben & Jerry's (Pistachio Pistachio): good pistachio flavor and creamy; not as creamy as Haagen-Dazs, but at least it tastes like actual pistachio flavor! 

Talenti (Sicilian Pistachio): Wonderful texture, and overwhelming (but in a good way) toasted pistachio flavor.  THIS is what pistachio ice cream (err, gelato) should be about. 

Hands down, the Talenti was the overall winner; Ben & Jerry's the winner of the ice cream subcategory.  Sadly, this was yet another disappointing strike in the other over-arching question, "Is Ciao Bella gelato worth the price?"  So far, we have yet to find a reason to buy one of their flavors a second time.  Let us know which ice creams you want us to taste-test, and we will put them in our rotation; until then, you can tune in to our next installment; "Which orange ice cream/sherbet/sorbetto is the best?"